• Sarah Mann
  • Posts
  • How to Give Honest Feedback in Year-End Performance Reviews

How to Give Honest Feedback in Year-End Performance Reviews

If the thought of year-end performance conversations makes you want to crawl into the fetal position, you're in good company.

Hey there -

If the thought of year-end performance conversations makes you want to crawl into the fetal position, you're in good company. PSL is back on every menu, and your calendar is slowly filling up with the meetings most managers dread.

The dread runs in both directions. Managers worry that they won't know what to say, that the employee will disagree, or that they'll get a question they can't answer. (All valid!)

Employees worry that they won't get a word in, that the feedback won't be fair, or that their manager doesn't understand what they do all day. (All valid!)

Most advice on this topic focuses on better scripts, and good scripts are useful. But when a leader tells me these conversations stress them out, it’s worth understanding why. 

When we do a little digging, what typically pops up is that they’re afraid of how an employee might respond. They don’t want to disappoint anyone, and they don’t want to be the recipient of anyone’s anger. 

That fear often comes from an unwritten rule: It's my job to make sure everyone is happy.

If the assumption is that an employee isn’t going to be happy with the merit increase, lack of promotion, or the feedback, it translates to fear and anxiety. 

It can also turn an opportunity for helpful, usable insight for an employee into a word salad. No calories. Says nothing. 

There are three common ways this rule makes performance conversations go sideways. I call them The Three D's.

  • Deflecting happens when you abdicate responsibility for the assessment and pin it on someone else, such as HR or senior leadership. You might think it’s protecting your relationship with the employee. What it's really doing is costing you your leadership credibility. Own whatever feedback you provide, even if it's uncomfortable.

  • Diluting happens when you soften critical feedback with so many caveats, modifiers, and extraneous words that the recipient has no idea what you said. In the moment it might feel like you’re being kind. It does nothing to support the employee who may walk away feeling resentful at the lack of feedback or mixed messages. Clear is kind. (Thank you, Brené Brown.)

  • Defending happens when you argue your case point by point after someone pushes back. Do your homework, bring specific examples, and keep your tone neutral. Pretend you’re talking about the weather. Most people don't get too worked up about the weather.

By the end of the conversation, your employee should be able to articulate: 

  • Where they stand

  • What you expect

  • What strong performance looks like moving forward

  • What you'll do to support them

If you've been having regular one-on-ones all year, none of it should come as news. (If it does, that means you probably missed opportunities during the year to offer your observations, or the message wasn’t clear.).

The best of these meetings feel like a conversation, not a lecture. Ask people what they're proud of, what really frustrated them, and what they want to take on next year. Then let them talk. 

Please don't skip the career conversation, either. A lack of career path comes up in almost every engagement survey I've seen. You aren't responsible for mapping out their whole career, because that part is on them, but you can help them brainstorm skills to build, training to try, and paths they hadn't considered. (I wrote more about the career conversation here.)

And if you walk away from the conversation and you feel like you blew it, you can always go back. 

Maybe you forgot something important, or you thought of a better way to say it. A short follow-up is all it takes:

  • "I've been thinking about our talk, and I could have been clearer about…"

  • "That point you made about X was valid, and I'd like to dig into it a little more."

  • "We ran out of time to talk about your career goals. Do you have 15 minutes this week?"

A follow-up tells your employee you were still thinking about the conversation after it ended,  and that's worth more than getting it perfect on the first try.

So while your colleagues are curled up in the fetal position, you can sip your PSL and maybe even look forward to these conversations. (Or at least not dread them.) ☕️

S

STAY CONNECTED

Did someone forward this to you? Sign up here for my free weekly note where I share real-time, actionable thoughts on leadership, building leadership fluency, and occasionally cute pictures of my dog.

Connect with me on LinkedIn where I post about Leadership Fluency™, executive presence, networking, mindset, and wellbeing.

WORK WITH ME

If you’re a leader looking for a coach who will help you cut through the BS — yours and others — let’s talk.

Executive Coaching — 1:1 for VP through C-suite leaders. Direct, confidential, unshockable. The work is identity-level — the unwritten rules you’ve been following without realizing it.

Corporate Leadership Development — For organizations supporting more than one leader. Coaching network, team development, and cohort programs, all built on the Leadership Fluency™ framework.

Keynote Speaking — For leadership teams, offsites, and conferences. Topics: Leadership Fluency™ and the unwritten rules that keep leaders stuck.

If any of this sounds familiar, let's talk. [email protected] | 617-306-6037